Hotels in Fishers Island

Whispers of the Waves: Discover the Hidden Charms of Fishers Island

Escape to Fishers Island, New York—a serene gem nestled between Long Island Sound and Block Island Sound. This exclusive retreat offers pristine beaches, lush landscapes, and a charming, laid-back atmosphere perfect for romantic getaways or family adventures. Explore the island’s rich maritime history at the Fishers Island Museum, unwind on the tranquil shores of Crescent Beach, or embark on scenic bike rides through the coastal beauty. With its captivating sunsets and a welcoming community, Fishers Island is an idyllic off-the-beaten-path destination for those seeking relaxation and natural splendor.

Discover great hotels in Fishers Island

Fishers Island offers a variety of accommodations, from charming inns to upscale hotels, catering to different budgets. Prices can range widely depending on the season and type of lodging. Enjoy a peaceful getaway with beautiful views and a relaxed atmosphere, perfect for a memorable vacation. Here are some of our travelers' favorite hotels in Fishers Island:

1. Hilltop Express InnOpens in a new window: This 2.5-star motel offers a casual and comfortable lodging experience, perfect for leisure travelers. Guests can unwind with entertainment options including television and cable services. The property is ideally located near a variety of attractions, such as museums and outlet shopping, providing ample opportunities for exploration and enjoyment. Review sentiments highlight the welcoming atmosphere and the variety of nearby activities, ensuring a delightful stay for those seeking convenience and relaxation.
2. Harbor View LandingOpens in a new window: Harbor View Landing is a vibrant 2.5-star guesthouse tailored for adventurous travelers. With an emphasis on outdoor recreation, this property features thrilling onsite adventure sports such as fishing, motorboating, and kayaking. Nearby hiking and biking trails invite guests to explore the natural beauty of the area. The positive reviews showcase guests' appreciation for the immersive adventure experiences and the energetic ambiance, making it an ideal choice for those looking to embrace outdoor excitement and create unforgettable memories.
3. Hampton Inn GrotonOpens in a new window: This charming 2.5-star hotel provides a welcoming environment for LGBTQIA travelers and their pets. The property features thoughtful amenities such as food and water bowls and ensures a comfortable stay for all guests. Review sentiments reflect a strong appreciation for the inclusive atmosphere and the focus on creating a pet-friendly experience, allowing travelers to enjoy a unique getaway that caters to their diverse needs and preferences.

Top locations to stay in Fishers Island

When visiting Fishers Island, New York, great areas to stay in include Mystic, Groton, and Stonington. Mystic is charming for its historic port and aquarium, Groton offers excitement with its casinos and museums, while Stonington is perfect for families with its welcoming atmosphere. For first-time visitors, Mystic is the best choice due to its vibrant attractions.

1. MysticOpens in a new window: Mystic is a charming coastal town that offers a delightful blend of maritime history and family-friendly attractions. With its picturesque harbor and famous Mystic Seaport, you'll find opportunities to explore sailing ships and learn about the region's nautical heritage. The Mystic Aquarium is a must-visit, featuring engaging exhibits and interactive experiences with marine life. Mystic is also home to an array of unique shops and boutiques, perfect for picking up souvenirs. The town's vibrant atmosphere makes it an ideal base for enjoying scenic waterfront walks and indulging in local fare.
2. GrotonOpens in a new window: Groton is a great spot for travelers seeking a mix of cultural experiences and outdoor fun. Known for its scenic parks and waterfront, Groton offers beautiful views and opportunities for hiking and picnicking. The area features various cultural attractions, including art galleries and theaters showcasing local talent. Groton's proximity to nearby attractions allows for easy exploration, making it a convenient choice for those wanting to experience the best of southeastern Connecticut.
3. StoningtonOpens in a new window: Stonington is a quaint coastal village that boasts a rich history and beautiful beaches. Known for its charming streets lined with historic homes, it’s a great place to stroll and soak in the local culture. Stonington’s scenic coastline offers stunning views and opportunities for relaxation by the water. The town also features charming shops and galleries, making it a lovely stop for those looking to enjoy a slower pace while exploring local art and crafts.

Things to do in Fishers Island

Fishers Island beckons with its serene beaches, inviting waters for boating and sea diving, and scenic trails for hiking. Explore charming local shops, indulge in fresh seafood, and soak in stunning coastal views. It's a hidden gem for those seeking relaxation and outdoor fun in a picturesque setting.

• Mystic SeaportOpens in a new window – Dive into maritime history at this fascinating museum. Explore historic ships, learn about shipbuilding, and enjoy interactive exhibits that bring the sea to life.
• Naval Submarine Base New LondonOpens in a new window – While access may be limited, appreciate the significance of this vital naval facility. Take a moment to learn about its role in the U.S. Navy and the rich history surrounding submarine operations.
• Misquamicut State BeachOpens in a new window – Spend a day soaking up the sun on this beautiful sandy beach. Swim in the refreshing waters, stroll along the shore, or indulge in some beachside snacks while enjoying the ocean breeze.
• Montauk PointOpens in a new window – Head to this iconic spot to witness breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean. Take a scenic walk along the shoreline, and capture stunning photographs of the rugged coastline.
• Montauk Point LighthouseOpens in a new window – Make your way to this historic lighthouse, one of the oldest in New York. Climb to the top for panoramic views of the surrounding area and learn about its storied past in the attached museum.

4 tips for savvy savings when booking a hotel in Fishers Island

1. Book for the cheapest times: The most budget-friendly time to visit Fishers Island is from January to March, when hotel prices are typically lower. To fully enjoy the area's historical landmarks and cultural attractions, it’s best to plan for at least a 2 to 3-day stay. During this time, you can explore family-friendly sites, unique shopping options, and delightful dining experiences, all offering great value for money. Remember, prices may drop during these months, making it an affordable getaway for those on a budget.
2. Look for last-minute deals on Hotels.com: To uncover last-minute deals to Fishers Island, visit the “Deals” or “Last-Minute Deals” sections on Hotels.com, where you may discover discounted hotel rates as your travel date approaches. Consider enabling email alerts or push notifications from Hotels.com to stay informed about flash sales and special last-minute promotions, helping you seize opportunities to save. Additionally, the “Smart Shopping” tool available via the app allows you to compare hotel prices and amenities, so you’re more likely to see when rooms become available or prices drop, making it easier to book a spontaneous getaway.
3. Be flexible with dates: Prices can fluctuate based on factors like the hotel's location, star rating, and the time of year. Being flexible with your travel dates may help you find savings on your stay at a Fishers Island hotel. If you're interested in unique accommodations, boutique hotels often provide a more personalized experience and can sometimes offer better value. When you book through Hotels.com, we’ll inform you if the price for your chosen dates is above or below average. If the price seems high, we’ll suggest alternative dates that could help you find a more budget-friendly option.
4. Consider your location: Staying closer to major attractions or city centers can be convenient, but it often comes with a higher price tag. For more affordable options, you might consider hotels in less central neighborhoods, striking a balance between cost and accessibility to the sites you want to see. Exploring independent hotels that are a bit farther out can lead to a more authentic and budget-friendly experience, which usually tends to be cheaper.

Best time to go to Fishers Island

Fishers Island experiences its lowest average temperature in January, at 32.0°F (0.0°C), while July is the hottest month, with an average temperature of 73.0°F (22.8°C). October tends to be the wettest months.The peak travel months to visit Fishers Island are June to August, which see a higher number of tourists. During this peak period, the weather is mostly sunny, accompanied by light rainfall. In contrast, January, November, and December are ideal if you're looking for a calmer vacation, marked by light rainfall and mostly sunny conditions.