4 Star Hotels in Islamorada

Free cancellation options if plans change
Unlock travel rewards with One Key
Save more with Member Prices

Check prices for these dates

This weekend
Next weekend

Popular Islamorada 4-star hotels to try out

Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Top neighborhoods in Islamorada

Matecumbe

Matecumbe gives you the full Florida Keys experience without trying too hard. Snorkel crystal waters at Anne's Beach, grab a cold one at Florida Keys Brewing Co, or watch fishermen haul in their catch at Bud n' Mary's. The Hurricane Monument and Indian Key Historic State Park tell stories of this laid-back paradise, while the MoradaWay Arts District adds cultural flair. Waterfront tiki bars serve fresh mahi-mahi as the sun sets over Florida Bay. Most visitors stay in charming resorts with private beaches and pools, though vacation rentals offer more space. You'll need a car to explore properly, but many resort areas are perfectly walkable.

Lower Matecumbe Beach

Lower Matecumbe Beach offers pristine Atlantic shorelines where powder-soft sand meets crystal-clear turquoise waters. Sunset Drive Beach and nearby Anne's Beach provide perfect spots for swimming and sunbathing in the shallow, calm waters. You'll discover scenic overlooks at mile markers, historic fishing piers extending into Florida Bay, and the popular Founder's Park with its recreational facilities. Waterfront seafood restaurants serve fresh mahi-mahi and key lime pie with stunning ocean views. Accommodations range from luxury beachfront resorts to intimate bed-and-breakfasts. Getting around requires a rental car, though the beachfront areas are highly walkable with bike-friendly roads.

Venetian Shores

Venetian Shores offers the Keys dream—canal-front homes with private docks where dolphins practically introduce themselves at breakfast. Spend your days boating from your backyard to snorkeling spots or fishing the flats between the Atlantic and Florida Bay. This upscale residential enclave lets you live like a local without the tourist crowds. You'll need wheels to explore nearby attractions like Founders Park and the History of Diving Museum. The neighborhood itself has no restaurants or shops—just peaceful streets lined with luxury vacation rentals featuring pools and tropical gardens. For dining out, a quick 5-10 minute drive takes you to Islamorada's waterfront eateries.

Seabreeze Trailer Park

Seabreeze Trailer Park offers a laid-back slice of Florida Keys paradise without the resort price tag. You'll get direct beach access for swimming and snorkeling in crystal-clear waters. Nearby Founders Park and Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park provide perfect day trips. Rain Barrel Village offers local shopping when you need a break from all that sunshine. Seafood restaurants and waterfront dining options are just a short drive away in Islamorada. While public transit is limited, having a rental car or golf cart makes exploring the surrounding Keys a breeze. The peaceful, no-frills atmosphere makes this spot ideal for travelers seeking an authentic Keys experience on a budget.

Top landmarks in Islamorada

Find out more about 4 Star Hotels in Islamorada

Find out more about 4 Star Hotels in Islamorada

How affordable are 4-star hotels in Islamorada compared to 5-star options?

How affordable 4-star hotels in Islamorada are compared to 5-star options depends on several factors, such as property location. A 4-star hotel in Islamorada's most sought-after areas will typically cost more than a 5-star hotel that's a little further away from the main attractions. Luckily, you can quickly compare prices for 5-star and 4-star hotels in Islamorada with Hotels.com's easy-to-use search wizard. Enter your dates and destination, check the 4- and 5-star filters, and hit the search button. It'll then throw up real-time prices so you can get a feel for how they compare.

What services are typically offered at 4-star hotels in Islamorada?

Four-star hotels in Islamorada usually offer all the services you need for a comfortable stay, such as concierges, valet parking, and laundry facilities. Most 4-star properties also have at least one on-site restaurant serving delicious breakfasts, lunches, and dinners. You'll typically find an on-site bar and café, too. If it's R&R you're seeking, you'll be pleased to know that many upper mid-range hotels in Islamorada boast fitness centers, pools, and even spas with massages and treatments. Some even offer kid-friendly services, such as children's play areas and kids' clubs. Remember to use the search filters on Hotels.com if you need specific amenities or services.

Do Islamorada 4-star hotels offer flexible booking and free cancellation?

Yes, many 4-star hotels in Islamorada offer free cancellation when booked on Hotels.com, meaning you'll get a full refund if you change your mind. Be sure to double-check the booking policies before paying for your stay, as each property has different cancellation rules. Some may even have refundable and non-refundable rates for the same room. Luckily, all this information is crystal clear on Hotels.com. The “free cancellation” label indicates flexible booking, while the “fully refundable” search filter lets you instantly view the most flexible four-star hotels in Islamorada. If your plans change after booking, you can cancel your booking by logging into “Trips” and following the easy steps.

What are some highly rated 4-star hotels near Islamorada's city center?

Thanks to Hotels.com's handy search map, you can easily view some of the top-rated 4-star hotels near Islamorada's center. It not only shows you where each hotel is, but the pop-up also reveals the guest ratings based on countless reviews from fellow travelers. The “Exceptional,” “Wonderful,” and “Very good” ratings each indicate a score of 8 out of 10 or higher based on guest ratings. Click on the hotel page to read the comments, too. All reviews on Hotels.com are real, unfiltered, and unbiased, so you can trust the ratings you see. As well as the map, the “property location” and “guest rating” filters also let you view the top-rated four-star hotels near Islamorada's different areas.

What types of rooms and suites are available in 4-star hotels in Islamorada?

You'll find that most 4-star hotels in Islamorada offer a wide range of different room types. If you're seeking somewhere a little more spacious, you'll be pleased to know that the majority of upper-mid-range properties offer spacious suites with more room to stretch out. For a comfortable space for you and your kids, keep an eye out for family rooms, too. To view what rooms and suites each hotel has, click on its dedicated page, where you'll find a run-down of room types with an easy-to-read description. You'll see the size, inclusions, and cancellation policy.

Are there budget-friendly 4-star hotels near Islamorada with good reviews?

If you're seeking an affordable getaway, you'll find many well-rated cheap 4-star hotels in Islamorada. You can find these in a few easy clicks with Hotels.com's search filters, too. Use a combination of the “4-star rating” filter, the “Wonderful” or “Very good” guest rating filters, and the “max price” toggle bar to view top-rated four-star hotels in Islamorada within your budget. You can even enter the maximum amount you want to pay for your Islamorada 4-star hotel. Remember, One KeyOpens in a new window members unlock instant savings on thousands of hotels simply by signing in when searching for hotels. You can also access special discounts by searching and booking through the Hotels.com app. 

Are 4 star hotels in Islamorada suitable for business travelers?

The “Business friendly” traveler experience filter will reveal some of the best 4-star hotels in Islamorada for work. These properties typically boast everything you could need for a productive stay, including conference facilities, dedicated workspaces, and high-speed internet.

What amenities do 4-star hotels in Islamorada provide?

The amenities at four-star hotels in Islamorada usually include at least one on-site restaurant and bar, as well as a pool, fitness center, and even a spa. In many cases, you'll find family amenities, like a play area and even a kids' club. Remember, the search filters on Hotels.com let you pin down upper-mid-range hotels with the specific amenities you need. The detailed and up-to-date hotel descriptions on Hotels.com show what amenities you'll find at specific properties.

Keep exploring

Keep exploring